“ Originally Posted by D/\SH 
”
and you also have to look at it this way.... peyton manning had marvin harrison, brian greise (why throw him in there lmao) and delhomme (panthers fan) has steve smith..... who did vick have to throw it too? crumpler was his only consistant target..... and of the above teams, colts, bears, and carolina all had way better o-lines than vick did at atlanta..... if you put a good o-line in front of him at the same skill level if he gets back there wattch out fans philly may have a dynasty in the making... especially if westbrook and the rest of the team can actually stay healthy.
i used those qb's just to get a mix of talent. it's pretty easy saying vick's no manning. but if he's worse than griese or delhomme, over his whole career not just when carolina was hot, than that's gonna back up my statement more.
--------- New Post Merged on 16/8/2009 at 02:08:18 --------
“ Originally Posted by broSki ”
ya dunno what ya talkin about, vick Has amazing talent man...amazinggggggg. I believe he is a way better QB then Mcnabb is anyday. WHy? well b/c Mcnabb always had the better team to playw ith and vick had a bad team which by the way still made it to the playoffs, I mean eagles with their nice team still cant win a superbowl and had more then 8 opportunities in the last 10 yrs to try so....So with that said I wouldnt be surprised vick takes mcnabbs job...plus philly fans hate Mcnabb anyway so better for ya lol.
All I can say is GMEN STAND UP
broski....hahahahahahahahahaha...hahahaha.....but seriously, we'll see how much time gets behind center. i mean sure vick can run down the field but mcnabb can lead a team down the field. it's the intangables. if they're in an athletic skills competition, i'll take vick. but since we're talking qb's in the nfl it's gotta be mcnabb all the way.